Sessions Overrules BIA in Controversial Decision
Looking for A Specific Post? Search Below
In a move that has surprised few people, Attorney General Jeff Sessions has overturned a decision issued by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). This decision could negatively affect other people seeking asylum in the United States because of domestic violence or gang violence.
Ms. A-B’s Case
The facts of the case are easy enough to understand. An El Salvadoran woman applied for asylum in the U.S., alleging that she had suffered more than a decade of abuse in her home country at the hands of her husband. Even when she tried to get away, her husband followed her and raped her. In 2015, a Charlotte, North Carolina asylum judge denied Ms. A-B’s claim for asylum, consistent with this judge’s very low approval rate.
In December of 2016, the BIA overturned the immigration judge’s decision, finding that it was clearly erroneous. According to the BIA, Ms. A-B had shown that she suffered group-based persecution. In particular, she was an El Salvadoran woman who could not leave a domestic relationship because she had children in common with her abuser.
Usually, BIA decisions end the matter. However, Attorney General Sessions referred the case to himself, giving him the power to either reverse or affirm the BIA’s decision. As soon as Sessions issued the referral, observers expected him to overrule the BIA, which is exactly what he did.
According to Sessions, domestic violence and gang violence are crimes, but the fact that they are not effectively policed in foreign countries does not provide sufficient reason to grant asylum. In fact, he disparaged awarding asylum to those suffering from “private violence.” “The asylum statute does not provide redress for all misfortune,” he continued.
Controversial Ruling
Sessions’ decision did not pass unnoticed by practitioners and experts in immigration law. According to NBC News, a group comprising 15 former members of the BIA and other immigration judges have denounced the decision. Calling it “an affront to the rule of law,” they emphasized that awarding asylum to victims of domestic violence was the result of over 15 years of litigation and should not be overturned so breezily. They also called on appellate courts or Congress to change Sessions’ decision and reinstate asylum for people like Ms. A-B.
How This Might Affect You
The United States can grant asylum to those suffering persecution on account of their race, religion, nationality, and political opinion. There is also a catch-all category for those persecuted because they belong to a “particular social group.” This last category is undefined and leaves some leeway for the government to give asylum to a wider range of people—such as those suffering domestic violence or gang activity.
With the Attorney General’s intervention, however, immigration judges are less likely to find that domestic violence victims will qualify under the “particular social group” category. This, unfortunately, could lead to denials of worthy asylum applications—at least for the duration of the Trump Presidency.
Chicago Immigration Advice You can Trust
At Kriezelman Burton & Associates, we handle asylum claims and are here to discuss your situation. We have decades of combined experience and are anxious to put it to work for you. Please contact us for your consultation.
Co Mówią Nasi Klienci
Ocena 5 gwiazdek | Na podstawie 200+ pozytywnych opinii na Google
Mr. Jeffery and Mr. Kevin Racia were the attorneys handling a complex immigration case of mine. On the assurance of both attorneys that the case is going to be presented in a systematic way, I went ahead with confidence. I was able to become a legal permanent resident. I highly recommend Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC for all your immigration needs.
Thank you, thank you, thank you to the remarkable team of Khiabett Osuna, Brittani Rivera, and Rafael Rodriguez, who were responsible for the successful release from detention of one of our parishioners, husband and father of four, after over 10 weeks of incarceration. From his detention to the payment of his bail and from Immigration Court to his reunion with his family, there were blessings aplenty made possible through the…
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my attorney, Brittni Rivera, for her professionalism and support during a very difficult time. I was in detention for 6 months, and thanks to her hard work and filing a habeas corpus petition, I was finally released. In addition, when I was released, ICE did not return my documents. Brittni did not ignore this issue — she took action and successfully…
My aunt was recently detained by ICE and sent to El Paso, Texas to the East Montana Detention Facility. This place is essentially a prison in the middle of the desert, and the majority of the detainees here get deported. My family and I interviewed a dozen immigration attorneys around the country to help my aunt, and we decided to hire Kevin Raica, an attorney with Kriezelman Burton and Associates.…
Our case was very difficult, and at times it felt like there was no way out. My wife was detained for a long period of time, and it was an extremely challenging experience for our family. Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC truly changed our situation. I would especially like to thank our attorney, Brittni Rivera, as well as Natalia. They were attentive, honest, and always ready to help. It was…
I cannot recommend Kevin Raica highly enough. He helped me successfully obtain my U.S. green card, and the entire process was smooth and stress-free because of his expertise and dedication. From start to finish, Kevin was professional, organized, and extremely knowledgeable about immigration law. He made sure every document was prepared correctly and took the time to explain each step clearly. Anytime I had questions, he responded promptly and made…
Great experience with this attorney office. They helped me with my I-751 waiver after divorce. Kevin was very professional, and supported me through the interview. Everything went smoothly and my case was approved. Highly recommend!
We contacted Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC, based on a recommendation, when my wife was detained by ICE. Attorney Khiabett Osuna handled our case, and it turned out to be the right choice. From the very beginning, she proved herself to be a caring and competent professional, clearly explaining the process. You can tell she's truly invested in each case and achieving results for her clients. We've also heard of…
I would like to express my gratitude to Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC, and especially to attorney Khiabett Osuna, who handled my case. I contacted them based on a recommendation and have never regretted it. From the very beginning, she demonstrated high professionalism. I could tell she was genuinely committed to the outcome and was doing everything possible to protect her client.
Mr. Kriezelman, Mr. Burton and Ms. Erin Cobb, I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart for handling my case. Your knowledge and dedication to my case is truly appreciated. Thank you.
Schedule a consultation!:
Umów się na konsultację!
Libertyville
Reklama prawnika. Informacje te mają wyłącznie charakter ogólny. Przedstawionych informacji nie należy interpretować jako formalnej porady prawnej ani tworzenia relacji prawnik/klient. Wcześniejsze wyniki i referencje nie stanowią gwarancji, rękojmi ani przewidywania wyniku Twojej sprawy i nie powinny być w ten sposób interpretowane. Wyniki z przeszłości nie mogą zagwarantować przyszłych wyników. Jakikolwiek wynik w pojedynczej sprawie nie ma na celu stworzenia oczekiwań podobnych wyników w przyszłych sprawach, ponieważ każdy przypadek wiąże się z wieloma różnymi czynnikami, dlatego też wyniki będą się różnić w każdym przypadku. Podając dane kontaktowe, użytkownicy potwierdzają i wyrażają wyraźną zgodę na kontakt za pośrednictwem udostępnionych metod komunikacji, w tym wiadomości SMS. Mogą obowiązywać stawki za wiadomości i transmisję danych. Częstotliwość wiadomości może się różnić. Odpowiedz STOP, aby zrezygnować.
NUVEW | Prawo autorskie 2026 Wszelkie prawa zastrzeżone | Informacja o dostępności | polityka prywatności