Sessions Overrules BIA in Controversial Decision
Looking for A Specific Post? Search Below
In a move that has surprised few people, Attorney General Jeff Sessions has overturned a decision issued by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). This decision could negatively affect other people seeking asylum in the United States because of domestic violence or gang violence.
Ms. A-B’s Case
The facts of the case are easy enough to understand. An El Salvadoran woman applied for asylum in the U.S., alleging that she had suffered more than a decade of abuse in her home country at the hands of her husband. Even when she tried to get away, her husband followed her and raped her. In 2015, a Charlotte, North Carolina asylum judge denied Ms. A-B’s claim for asylum, consistent with this judge’s very low approval rate.
In December of 2016, the BIA overturned the immigration judge’s decision, finding that it was clearly erroneous. According to the BIA, Ms. A-B had shown that she suffered group-based persecution. In particular, she was an El Salvadoran woman who could not leave a domestic relationship because she had children in common with her abuser.
Usually, BIA decisions end the matter. However, Attorney General Sessions referred the case to himself, giving him the power to either reverse or affirm the BIA’s decision. As soon as Sessions issued the referral, observers expected him to overrule the BIA, which is exactly what he did.
According to Sessions, domestic violence and gang violence are crimes, but the fact that they are not effectively policed in foreign countries does not provide sufficient reason to grant asylum. In fact, he disparaged awarding asylum to those suffering from “private violence.” “The asylum statute does not provide redress for all misfortune,” he continued.
Controversial Ruling
Sessions’ decision did not pass unnoticed by practitioners and experts in immigration law. According to NBC News, a group comprising 15 former members of the BIA and other immigration judges have denounced the decision. Calling it “an affront to the rule of law,” they emphasized that awarding asylum to victims of domestic violence was the result of over 15 years of litigation and should not be overturned so breezily. They also called on appellate courts or Congress to change Sessions’ decision and reinstate asylum for people like Ms. A-B.
How This Might Affect You
The United States can grant asylum to those suffering persecution on account of their race, religion, nationality, and political opinion. There is also a catch-all category for those persecuted because they belong to a “particular social group.” This last category is undefined and leaves some leeway for the government to give asylum to a wider range of people—such as those suffering domestic violence or gang activity.
With the Attorney General’s intervention, however, immigration judges are less likely to find that domestic violence victims will qualify under the “particular social group” category. This, unfortunately, could lead to denials of worthy asylum applications—at least for the duration of the Trump Presidency.
Chicago Immigration Advice You can Trust
At Kriezelman Burton & Associates, we handle asylum claims and are here to discuss your situation. We have decades of combined experience and are anxious to put it to work for you. Please contact us for your consultation.
Lo que dicen nuestras clientas
Calificación de 5 estrellas | Basado en 200+ reseñas de clientes satisfechos en Google
Exceptional Legal Representation I want to sincerely thank Kevin Raica for handling my case so efficiently. From our very first meeting, he demonstrated confidence and a clear plan for moving forward, which put us at ease right away. He kept the process moving and resolved our case in a timely manner. His professionalism and dedication made a stressful situation much easier to navigate. I have already recommended his services to…
Kriezelman Burton & Associate are Excellent immigration law firm that understands and guide one through any immigration cases. Attorney Khiabett is one of their best attorneys you can trust, she understands, patient, attentive, and gives honest advice about any immigration case her client has. I HIGHLY recommend the law firm to anyone having immigration concerns. Thank you for all you do.
Outstanding experience and successful Green Card approval with Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC! The immigration process can often be stressful and overwhelming, but working with Kriezelman Burton & Associates, LLC in Chicago made the entire journey smooth, transparent, and successful from start to finish. I want to express my deepest gratitude to Justin Burton for his exceptional professionalism, strategic guidance, and confidence from day one. Knowing my case was in…
Great lawyer, helped us to get a green card in few months, so thanks a lot. Recommended
Kevin Raica literally saved my life. He helped me out of a dangerous situation that my previous attorney had put me in. After 17 years without status and 6.5 years of working with my previous attorney, I had experienced so many denials that I had completely lost hope. When I met Kevin, everything changed. He genuinely cared about my situation and gave me hope when I couldn’t see any for…
We sincerely thank the entire team for the professionalism, responsiveness, patience, and dedication shown throughout our case. From our very first visit, Justin reassured us that everything would be all right. Thank you, Khiabett, for your expertise, professionalism, and calm guidance before and during the interview, which greatly reduced our stress and gave us confidence. We also deeply appreciate Kamila's hard work, patience, and responsiveness throughout the process. For sorting…
I would like to sincerely thank Attorney Justin Burton and PL Kamila Lada for support with my adjustment of status case. I have been working with the firm for over a year now, and I have received nothing short of exceptional services and support throughout various cases for myself and family members. Highly recommend consulting and retaining this firm.
We have been in the dark with our case for over 2 decades, while working with other big firms who just kept me in the dark and sat on our case without making any effort to move it forward until I met the wonderful team at Kriezelman & Burton. AO and JP are truly God-sent angels who with their knowledge, collaboration, sense of direction and outside the box thinking, managed…
Highly recommend attorney Kevin Raica and attorney Agata Bigdanowicz. They were super helpful, responded on time, and won my case in record time. It took about a month and half in total for me to get my approval after filing!
Brittni Rivera and her team (Carina Lopez) are fantastic! They are responsive, efficient and beyond compassionate. Brittni Rivera and her team treated me with dignity and respect as they patiently answered all of my questions. They didn't move on without making sure I understood each step. Their work ethic was impressive. It felt like they were an extension of my personal team. I can't say enough to convey my gratitude…
¡Programe una consulta!
Publicidad de abogados. Esta información está diseñada solo para información general. La información presentada no debe interpretarse como asesoramiento legal formal ni como la formación de una relación abogado/cliente. Los resultados y testimonios anteriores no son garantía ni predicción del resultado de su caso, y no deben interpretarse como tales. Los resultados pasados no pueden garantizar el rendimiento futuro. Cualquier resultado en un solo caso no pretende crear una expectativa de resultados similares en asuntos futuros porque cada caso involucra muchos factores diferentes, por lo tanto, los resultados diferirán caso por caso. Al proporcionar información de contacto, los usuarios reconocen y dan su consentimiento explícito para ser contactados a través de los métodos de comunicación proporcionados, incluido SMS. Se pueden aplicar tarifas por mensajes y datos. La frecuencia de los mensajes puede variar. Responda STOP para optar por no participar.
NUVEW | Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved | Accessibility Notice | privacy policy